In Depth Baby Product Reviews Led by a Pediatrician

Creative Baby Tidy Review

Great option to contain the stink and stay in your budget long term
gearlab tested logo
creative baby tidy diaper pail review
Credit: Abriah Wofford
Price:  $60 List
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Manufacturer:   Creative Baby
By Abriah Wofford ⋅ Senior Review Editor  ⋅  Apr 20, 2020
82
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#2 of 11
  • Odor Control - 60% 8.0
  • Ease of Diaper Disposal - 25% 8.0
  • Ease of Bag Change - 15% 9.0

The Skinny

The Creative Baby Tidy's ability to keep in the stink, even when depositing diapers impressed us during testing. Combined with its overall useability and the savings of utilizing regular kitchen trash bags, this pail won us over and earned the Best Value award. Somewhat smaller than average, its size does not impact its overall performance, and likely will help keep the poopy diaper smell to a minimum. The unique rotating lid and piston system makes for nearly effortless diaper deposits. While there are some complaints about this pail being less durable than some other brands, we think that it is sturdy enough to last through your baby's diapering years.
REASONS TO BUY
Great odor control
Easy to operate
Uses regular trash bags
REASONS TO AVOID
Small size
Wipes may get stuck

Compare to Similar Products

 
creative baby tidy diaper pail review
This Product
Creative Baby Tidy
Awards Editors' Choice Award Editors' Choice Award Best Value Award   
Price $60 List$74 List
$70.95 at Amazon
$35 List
$27.99 at Amazon
$30 List
$29.99 at Amazon
$36 List
$28.95 at Amazon
Overall Score Sort Icon
82
85
74
55
53
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros Great odor control, easy to operate, uses regular trash bagsBest odor control, large capacity, self-sealing, durable, easy bag changeVery good odor control, unscented liners, small size, easy to use, cloth coversAffordable, simple to use, one-handed disposalConvenient, large capacity, saves space, easy to clean and use
Cons Small size, wipes may get stuckLavendar scent can be overwhelming, small opening, expensive, proprietary bagsNo foot pedal, proprietary bagsDoesn't reduce smells, plastic constructionZipper can be difficult, average smell containment, cloth will wear over time
Bottom Line Great option to contain the stink and stay in your budget long termGreat odor control with a large capacity makes this pail a winnerSmaller diaper pail with good odor controlBasic pail with minimal stink containment, but a budget-friendly priceWhimsical, convenient, and space-saving way to hamper dirty cloth diapers
Rating Categories Creative Baby Tidy Munchkin Step Playtex Genie Expre... Safety 1st Easy Saver Planet Wise Hanging...
Odor Control (60%)
8.0
9.0
8.0
4.0
5.0
Ease of Diaper Disposal (25%)
8.0
8.0
6.0
7.0
3.0
Ease of Bag Change (15%)
9.0
7.0
7.0
9.0
10.0
Specs Creative Baby Tidy Munchkin Step Playtex Genie Expre... Safety 1st Easy Saver Planet Wise Hanging...
Dimensions 11.5"W x 15"D x 16"H 12"W x 10"D x 27"H 11"W x 11"D x 21"H 14"W x 14"D x 19"H 16"W x 26.5"H
Type of Refill Trash Bag Proprietary Liner Proprietary Liner Trash Bag No Bag
Refill Cost $14 $8 $7 $14 $0
Estimated Lifetime Cost of Refills $53 $292 $260 $53 $0
Estimated Total Cost of Ownership $113 $357 $285 $73 $34
One-Handed Operation Yes Yes No Yes No
Foot-Pedal Opener No Yes No No No
Material Plastic Plastic Plastic Plastic Cotton/PUL
Childproof Safety Lock No No No No No

Our Analysis and Test Results

Founded in 2011, Creative Baby is a company that is attempting to put a funky and innovative twist on your standard baby products. They draw inspiration for their prints and colors from the different localities of their home base in Southern California. They offer various baby supplies such as walkers, bouncers, toys, playmats and more.

Performance Comparison



creative baby tidy diaper pail review - the creative baby tidy has one of the least hands-on disposal...
The Creative Baby Tidy has one of the least hands-on disposal methods of the group.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Likes


The Creative Baby Tidy is a medium-sized diaper pail that has a two-sided rotating lid that deposits diapers in the receptacle without ever having to open it up to the room. The lid opening mechanism is childproof, but still easy to open with one hand when changing the bag.

We are fans of just about every aspect of the Creative Baby Tidy. This plastic diaper pail holds in dirty diaper odor better than most others in our review, releasing only a small poof when the piston drops. The rotating lid is one of the only systems to ensure there is never any direct airflow in or out of the pail, therefore preventing the stink from escaping. This type of lid also prevents curious toddlers from getting into the dirty diapers within. It is easy to operate with one hand, and the dropping piston found in the cover solves the problem of diapers getting stuck and provides the extra little push without you having to get more involved.

The generously sized opening of the Creative Baby Tidy allows...
The generously sized opening of the Creative Baby Tidy allows diapers to fall in freely.
You can rotate the lid of the Creative Baby Tidy easily with one hand.
You can rotate the lid of the Creative Baby Tidy easily with one hand.

The Tidy diaper pail falls in the middle of the pack in terms of upfront cost. However, it uses regular kitchen trash bags as liners, so in the long run, it is much more affordable than many other pails, while performing near the top of the pack in terms of odor control. We also love that the entire lid is removable and dishwasher safe. This way, if anything leaks from the diaper, you can give it a rinse and then toss it in the dishwasher for thorough sanitization. We much prefer this method over handwashing.


Dislikes


The process of changing out a full bag of diapers is one of the pail's downfalls. You must open the lid completely, and after that, it is essentially like changing a regular trash can. There is no way to keep the smell from hitting you full force other than moving through the process as fast as possible. That said, there are no complicated maneuvers or cutting devices to this pail; it is pretty straightforward.

Opening the lid of the Creative Baby Tidy requires pushing a button...
Opening the lid of the Creative Baby Tidy requires pushing a button and pulling a handle, but it is easily manageable with one hand.
When you open the lid of the Creative Baby Tidy, you are hit full...
When you open the lid of the Creative Baby Tidy, you are hit full force with the diaper stench.

Occasionally, wipes may get stuck in the cracks of the lid, and you will have to fish them out. This problem is easily remedied by placing the wipes in the dirty diaper and dropping the whole package as one while being sure to tuck in any loose ends. The most common complaint among parents is the size; it is a bit smaller than many of the other pails in our review. We think there are pros and cons to this, though. On the downside, you will have to empty the contents more frequently. On the upside, more frequent bag changes mean that there will be less accumulated stink, and changing the bag will be less of a hassle.

creative baby tidy diaper pail review - although changing the bag was our least favorite part of this pail...
Although changing the bag was our least favorite part of this pail, it was fairly quick and straightforward.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Conclusion


The Creative Baby Tidy is a pail we love so much we would use it in our own homes. The low stink factor impressed us initially, and the more we use it, the more we find that we prefer it. The innovative lid design sets it apart from most other products, and the simplicity of the rest of the pail makes it easy to use. The Tidy is one of our favorite dirty diaper vessels out there, and we would recommend it to anyone looking for a traditional diaper disposal system.

Abriah Wofford
 

You Might Also Like

Honest, objective reviews. Led by a Pediatrician.

BabyGearLab was founded by a Pediatrician Mom with a mission to provide a reliable, independent, source of information to new parents. Our experts have tested thousands of baby and kids products to share key performance, health, and safety findings. We spend tens of thousands of dollars crash testing car seats to inform our ratings. And, we combine our review work with gobs of expert parenting advice. To assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing by people who care.

Learn More